Selection Process for Unit Personnel Committees
Document history:
Ver 1.0: Approved by faculty on January 26, 2018.
Ver 1.1 Revised in March 2018—following faculty consultation—on the advice of the administration. Ver 1.1 approved by the administration and UHPA and implemented in 2018-2019 AY.
Ver 1.3 (this document) Minor revisions were approved by faculty vote in January 2019.
Routing and Responsibility
All faculty in the College applying for contract renewal, tenure, or promotion shall be evaluated by a Unit Personnel Committee composed of five (5) Unit 07 tenured faculty chosen from within the College. Faculty serving on unit personnel committees will either be selected by a faculty vote or, in some cases, appointed by a committee of department chairs.
Any department or equivalent unit that has six (6) or more full-time faculty members may choose between 1) forming a Cluster Personnel Committee (CPC) with related departments, or 2) forming its own Department Personnel Committee (DPC) composed of tenured department members.
The following procedure will apply if a Department or School votes to form its own DPC. The Department Chair or Director must notify the Dean of that decision prior to September 1. Departments forming their own DPC must comply with the UHPA contract and timeline. Formation of a DPC may impact other departments in their cluster. Therefore, faculty in a department with its own DPC are not exempt from serving on their cluster’s CPC.
Any department or equivalent unit that has less than six (6) or more full-time faculty members will form a Cluster Personnel Committee (CPC) with departments in related disciplines.
The clusters are: (1) Mathematics and Computer Science, (2) the School of Nursing and the Department of Kinesiology and Exercise Sciences, (3) Biology and Marine Science, and (4) Chemistry, Geology, and the Department of Physics and Astronomy.
Following the evaluation of an applicant by the Unit Personnel Committee, the applicant shall be independently assessed by a tenured department chair (or the Director of the School of Nursing) and this will serve as a second level of peer review. The dossier will be routed from the Unit Personnel Committee to that department chair and then to the Dean. In the case of contract renewal, the assessment and recommendations will be presented to the candidate prior to forwarding to the Dean [Article XII.E.2]. The department chair performing the independent assessment shall normally be chair of the applicant's department; however, departments participating in cluster personnel committees may, upon majority vote of all faculty within the cluster, adopt a process whereby a department chair within the cluster may serve as the evaluator for applicants from other departments within the cluster. For example, a cluster of departments may elect to rotate the responsibility for review among the chairs.
Any Department Chair or Director who has responsibility for being an independent faculty evaluator is prohibited [Article X, section B] from participating in the personnel-committee discussions of any applicant in their Department or cluster. They could, however, serve on the personnel committee of another cluster.
Procedures for Forming Committees
The procedure for elections to unit personnel committees is as follows:
Deadlines for applicants are announced by August 15.
Before September 1, the Dean prepares and distributes: (i) a list of applicants for contract renewal or promotion, divided by rank and department; (ii) a list of CHNS faculty members eligible to serve on personnel committees (tenured I-4 and I-5, not on leave during the fall, not in the terminal year of their contract, not under consideration for contract renewal, not applying for tenure or promotion, and not a Chair or Director that will be performing as an independent faculty reviewer); and (iii) a list of those eligible to vote on membership in personnel committees (I-2, I-3, I-4 and I-5, not on leave), divided by department.
Cluster Personnel Committees (CPCs) evaluate candidates who are at the rank of I-2 or I-3 at the time of application. Each CPC will review: (i) contract renewals for I-2 and I-3 applicants, (ii) promotion applications for I-2 and I-3 applicants, and (iii) tenure applications for I-3 applicants. All members of a CPC will be tenured Unit 07 faculty at the rank of I-4 or I-5. They shall be chosen from within the College.
Each cluster’s faculty will elect, from those eligible, a pool of faculty who might serve on their CPC:
- The vote shall be conducted using a ranked-vote procedure (i.e., first choice as 1, second as 2). Voters will rank all eligible tenured faculty members in their own department. They will also rank all eligible tenured faculty from the other department(s) in their cluster.
- Rank sum voting breaks down if any voter fails to rank everyone on the ballot. Any ballot that fails to rank all persons on a departmental ballot will be treated as follows. Blanks will be assigned the lowest possible rank. For example, if there are five people on ballot and only the top two are ranked, then all the remaining three will be assigned a rank of 5.
- The votes will be summed; the faculty members with the lowest sums will serve on one or more CPCs as determined by the CPC Selection Committee (see below). Ties are broken by random selection.
The fifth faculty member of a CPC is an at-large member that is selected from departments or schools that are outside the cluster but within the College. These members provide an outside perspective. They will be selected by random draw; the slate for the random draw will be comprised of all eligible CNHS faculty not voted onto personnel committees.
Candidates at the rank of I-4 (those seeking promotion to full professor) will be reviewed by a college-wide I-5 Personnel Committee (I-5 PC) comprised of tenured I-5 faculty drawn from within the College. Eligible I-3, I-4, and I-5 faculty shall vote for representatives to this committee.
- The slate will consist of eligible I-5 faculty, divided by department. Department chairs and School Directors are excluded from the slate unless they are not performing an independent evaluation of any candidate. The voting process shall be the same rank sum procedure used for the CPC elections (section 4, above).
- Faculty are assigned to the I-5 Personnel Committee based on the following principles:
- Each cluster shall supply two representatives to the I-5 Personnel Committee and there should be at least one representative from each department (or school) with candidates. If a cluster has no has no candidates then the CPC Selection Committee has the option to reduce the number of representatives from that cluster. The CPC Selection Committee is also authorized to make adjustments to departmental/cluster representation if the pool of eligible faculty is insufficient. The total number of faculty on the I-5 Personnel Committee will normally be eight and is never less than six.
- If a faculty member is voted onto both the I-5 Committee and a Cluster Committee, then the Selection Committee has the option of assigning them to either a Cluster Committee or the I-5 Committee. If a department has insufficient I-5 faculty, however, it is possible that an I-5 faculty member may be compelled to serve on both committees.
- Ballots will normally be distributed before candidates for I-4 to I-5 promotion submit their dossiers. If no dossiers for I-4 to I-5 promotion are submitted, then the Selection Committee may disband the I-5 Personnel Committee and rotate disbanded members onto CPC according to the normal rules of committee assignments. This must be done before committee assignments are announced.
- Each I-5 candidate is evaluated by five reviewers. The I-5 Personnel Committee itself will determine who steps out for a particular candidate. This choice shall be guided by the principle that candidates should be reviewed by those with similar expertise. Also, it is preferred that reviewers be drawn from each gender, if possible.
The chairs of all departments and the director of the School or Nursing will convene to appoint a CPC Selection Committee that will be composed of one Department Chair/Director from each cluster. The representative from each cluster will be from the department with the most candidates that year. If this results in a committee comprised entirely of one sex, however, then there can be flexibility in terms of which of a cluster’s chairs is appointed to the Selection Committee, if this results in better gender balance. Department chairs have the option of requesting that the Dean’s office facilitate scheduling of Selection Committee meetings.
The CPC Selection Committee will assign faculty who received the most votes (after adjustments described in paragraph 10) to the appropriate CPC (Paragraph 9). They will also appoint at-large committee members from outside the cluster using the procedures outlined in paragraph 5. The Selection Committee will also produce a ranked list of CPC alternates to step in where recusals or circumstances require. The CPC Selection committee also assigns faculty to the I-5 PC using procedures outlined in paragraph 6.b. The Selection Committee will appoint one member of each committee as the convener, who will not necessarily be the committee chair.
To the extent possible, the CPC Selection Committee shall assign CPC committee members as follows:
Math-Computer Science
- two eligible members from each department (selected by vote; four total), and
- one eligible at-large member (selected by random draw from other clusters)
Biology-Marine Science
- two eligible members from each department (selected by vote; four total), and
- one eligible at-large member (selected by random draw from other clusters)
Nursing-KES
- two eligible members from each department (selected by vote; four total), and
- one eligible at-large member (selected by random draw from other clusters)
Astronomy/Physics-Chemistry-Geology
- Two eligible members from each department (selected by vote; 6 total), and
- one eligible at-large member (selected by random draw from other clusters)
Ideally, each applicant is reviewed by two members of their department, one member each from the other two departments in the cluster, and one at-large member from outside the cluster. The CPC itself will determine, on a case-by-case basis, which two committee members step out for a particular candidate.
Alternates
Additional alternates, if needed, will be selected on a case-by-case basis in consultation with the CPC Selection Committee.
- The CPC Selection Committee may make adjustments to committee membership or alternates based on the following guidelines:
- Each I-2 or I-3 applicant should ideally have two reviewers from their department; failing this, there will be one reviewer from their department.
- Adjustments that are necessitated by recusals and insufficient numbers of eligible reviewers shall be made on the basis of random selection from pools of eligible reviewers with the most appropriate expertise available. In most cases this means the composition of the CPC should be filled by cluster members.
- Exemptions from service on Personnel Committees may be granted for reasons such as family or medical leave, frequent service in previous years, or unusual high duty loads. The CPC Selection Committee has the authority to grant exceptions in exceptional cases and may seek the advice of the Dean in this matter.
- If possible, committees should have at least two members of each sex.
- The CPC Selection Committee is consulted when unforeseen or special circumstances arise that affect committee members or the independent faculty evaluator.
Responsibilities of Personnel Committees
At its first meeting, each personnel committee shall select a chair. Only individuals who have previously served on a personnel committee are eligible to serve as chair. The advice of the CPC Selection Committee should be sought if no one on the committee has previously served on a personnel committee.
All members of personnel committees, the department chairs serving as independent reviewers, and the Dean shall sign a confidentiality statement prior to viewing the dossiers of any applicant. No personal or personnel information of any kind, including voting, may be discussed outside the personnel committee.
Dossiers should not be examined until the after submission deadlines and preliminary meetings are completed. Preliminary meetings include consultation or informational meetings, as needed, with UHPA representatives or the EEO.
Applicants for promotion, tenure, and/or contract renewal may include letters in their dossier which are written by individuals who are selected to serve on personnel committees. They may also include letters in their dossier from their department chair (or school director), even if the department chair/director is serving as an independent faculty evaluator.
Committees must not examine dossiers until decisions on committee membership have been made for each applicant.
Recusal is appropriate when a reviewer is unable to provide an unbiased review of a particular applicant. Merely writing a letter of recommendation, providing peer evaluation of teaching skills, or collaborating in scholarly endeavors does not constitute a priori grounds for recusal. Recusal is open to discussion by the Committee. Recusals must be in writing and Committees should not examine dossiers until all recusals have been reviewed and approved/rejected.
When deliberating on applications for contract renewal, the Committees, the independent faculty evaluator, and the Dean shall adhere to relevant sections of the current agreement between UHPA and the BOR.
During its review of an application, the committees may request additional pertinent material from the applicant. This will not serve as a due-date extension for poorly prepared dossiers, and committees will use due care in exercising this option. The committee chair will make a written request to the applicant for specific additional pertinent material. The applicant will have five (5) business days to provide the requested materials and will not use the opportunity to submit new material unrelated to the request.
All voting shall be conducted by secret ballot. The secret ballot counts should be retained by the chairs until all promotion, tenure, and contract renewal procedures are complete for that year and the appeal process is exhausted. After conclusion of personnel business for the year, including addressing any and all timely (per UHPA) grievance proceedings (if any), all notes and ballots will be destroyed to protect the privacy of all applicants.
General voting procedures for Personnel Committees
Ballots and the ballot box will be prepared by college office staff under supervision of the Dean, who will review the ballot. The voting process will be clearly provided on the ballot, and it is recommended that 1) sample ballets be provided, and 2) the ballot instructions state the consequence of not ranking all members of a department. The ballot box will be maintained in the Dean’s office. Ballots may be submitted during regular office hours, 7:30 a.m.–4:30 p.m. A faculty member must submit her/his own ballot to the ballot box and should not submit for another faculty member. Departmental elections will remain open for a minimum of four (4) days and all ballots must be returned to the locked ballot box located in the CNHS office before 4:15 PM on the final day of election. Votes will be tallied and summed by at least two members of the CPC Selection Committee. The faculty members receiving the lowest vote sum will be assigned to CPC(s) by the CPC Selection Committee. Similar procedures apply for the I-5 Committee. Ties are broken by random selection.
The Selection Committee will report the following to the Dean: 1) the election results (ranking of each department’s faculty based on the lowest vote sum), 2) committee assignments, and 3) the ranked alternates. The Dean or CPC Selection Committee will contact those appointed to Committees within two weeks of the vote. The Dean will inform the VCAA of the final membership of each Committee.
Candidate Forms
For contract renewal, the reappointment application form is recommended by the faculty of the College and distributed by the Dean. [Article XII, E.2] For tenure and promotion, the application form is initiated by the Vice Chancellor of Academic Affairs.
Revision History
Original document distributed on 01/19/2018 and approved by faculty on 01/26/2018.
Following faculty consultation, this document was revised in March 2018 to use a single college-wide committee for evaluation of candidates seeking promotion to the I-5 rank. The college-wide I-5 PC replaces four I-5 Cluster Committees in the original document. In addition, procedures for the School of Nursing were made parallel to the other units. Editorial changes were also made, and clarification of the rank sum procedures.
Revised in January 2019 and approved by faculty vote on 1/23/2019. The more substantive of the revisions make the voting procedures simpler and give more flexibility to the Selection Committee.